Simon Gray Realty
SearchCommunitiesOur Listings
AboutAgents & OfficesBlogContact
Simon Gray Realty

Florida's Premier Coastal Realty

Quick Links

  • Search
  • Communities
  • Our Listings
  • Meet Simon Gray
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

Contact Us

  • 719 Northlake Blvd North Palm Beach, FL 33408
  • properties@simongrayrealty.com
  • 888-321-1617
© 2026 Simon Gray Realty. All rights reserved.
1 / 22
View Virtual Tour

31473 Warner Street

Big Pine Key, FL 33043

3 bd·4 ba·2,087 sqft

$2,450,000

31473 Warner Street

Big Pine Key, FL 33043

$2,450,000

Active

Welcome to an exquisite open-water retreat in Big Pine Key, an unparalleled blend of modern luxury and authentic Keys lifestyle. This completely updated and remodeled 3BD/4BA pool home offers panoramic water views from every angle, setting the stage for endless sunrises, sunsets, and starry nights. Designed with sophistication and comfort in mind, each bedroom is an ensuite, ensuring privacy and convenience for family and guests. Beyond its beauty, this property is one of the rare few in Monroe County allowing nightly vacation rentals, boasting a highly successful rental history for those seeking both personal enjoyment and income opportunity. Every detail has been thoughtfully curated, impact windows and doors, corian countertops and two on-demand water heaters reflect quality and peace of mind. The boating enthusiast will appreciate one of the few marked channel systems leading directly to the Gulf of Mexico with the Atlantic Ocean just minutes away. Utilize the 220 sq ft extended dock for your vessel to some the best fishing, diving and boating in the continental U.S. Whether lounging poolside, entertaining on the spacious decks or heading out on the water this property offers an unmatched Keys experience. Rare, refined and ready for your investment this is open-water living at its finest.

3Beds
4Baths
2,087Sq Ft
28Days on Market

Details

MLS Number
A12099164
List Date
September 29, 2026
Year Built
1978
Living Area
2,087 sqft
Status
Active
Property Type
Residential
Style
SingleFamilyResidence

Property Info

Summary

Location and General Information

  • •City and Location Text: Big Pine Key
  • •County Or Parish: Monroe
  • •MLS Area: 5940 - Other Florida County
  • •MLS Sub Area: Other
  • •Postal Code: 33043
  • •State: FL
  • •Street #: 31473
  • •Subdivision / Complex: Big Pine Key Inc
  • •Parcel ID: 00110440000000
  • •Front Exposure: Northeast
  • •Zoning: SR

Taxes and HOA Information

  • •Annual Taxes: $15,342
  • •Tax Year: 2024

Parking

  • •Garage Spaces: 0 spaces
  • •Covered Spaces: 0
  • •Parking: Boat,Covered,Guest,Rv Access Parking

School Information

  • •Elementary School: Sugarloaf
  • •Middle School: Marathon
  • •High School: Key West

Virtual Tour

  • •Unbranded Virtual Tour: https://www.propertypanorama.com/instaview/mia/A12099164

Property

Lot Information

  • •Lot Acres: 1.79
  • •Zoning: SR

Building Information

  • •Year Built: 1978
  • •Living Area: 2,087 sqft
  • •Building Area Total: 5,923 sqft
  • •Full Baths: 4
  • •Half Baths: 0
  • •Stories: 1
  • •Property Condition: Resale,Updated Remodeled

Interior & Exterior

Interior

  • •Flooring: Tile
  • •Heating: Central
  • •Cooling: Central Air
  • •Patio/Porch: Open,Balcony
  • •Appliances: Dryer,Dishwasher,Electric Water Heater,Disposal,Ice Maker,Microwave,Refrigerator,Washer
  • •Interior Features: Built In Features,Closet Cabinetry,Dining Area,Separate Formal Dining Room,Eat In Kitchen,Other,Storage,Tub Shower,Upper Level Primary,Vaulted Ceilings,Bar

Exterior

  • •Construction: Frame
  • •Roof: Metal
  • •Foundation: Pillar Post Pier
  • •Exterior Features: Balcony,Outdoor Living Area,Outdoor Shower,Other

Utilities

  • •Water Source: Public
  • •Sewer: Public Sewer

Association & Community

Association & Community

  • •Association Amenities: Other

Directions & Tours

  • •Directions: US 1 to Beach Drive on Big Pine Key, take a left at the stop sign, house is on the right. Can also access via Avenue A to Warner Road and house will be on the left.
  • •Virtual Tour: https://www.propertypanorama.com/instaview/mia/A12099164

Location

Map showing location of 31473 Warner Street

Listed by Langley Knight Gardner Islamorada · Benton W Langley

Listing data provided by BeachesMLS · MLS #A12099164.

Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 BeachesMLS. All rights reserved.

Listing History

September 29, 2026Listed$2,450,000
CurrentDays on Market28 days
SourceBeachesMLSMLS #A12099164

Mortgage Calculator

$
$
$

Estimated Monthly Payment

$16,510.76

Principal & Interest

$13,039.93

Taxes

$2,450.00

Insurance

$1,020.83

This is an estimate for illustrative purposes only. Actual payments will vary. Consult a licensed mortgage professional.

Quick Facts

Status
Active
MLS #
A12099164
Days on Market
28 days
Type
Residential
Year Built
1978
Lot Size
1.79 ac
Price / Sqft
$1,174/sqft
Annual Taxes
$15,342
Neighborhood
Big Pine Key Inc
County
Monroe

Schedule a Tour

Your information is kept private and never sold.

Similar Homes Nearby

1669 Lantana Lane, Big Pine Key
Active
45
Active
  • 2 Bedrooms
  • 2 Bathrooms
  • 988 Sq Ft
View Details
$895,000
1d on market
2 bd·2 ba·988 sqft

1669 Lantana Lane

Big Pine Key, FL 33043

MLS# A12113308

30995 Watson Boulevard, Big Pine Key
Active
52
Active
  • 4 Bedrooms
  • 3 Bathrooms
View Details
$2,300,000
4d on market
4 bd·3 ba

30995 Watson Boulevard

Big Pine Key, FL 33043

MLS# A12111941

173 Cahill Court, Big Pine Key
Active
54
Active
  • 3 Bedrooms
  • 2 Bathrooms
  • 1,020 Sq Ft
View Details
$1,100,000
18d on market
3 bd·2 ba·1,020 sqft

173 Cahill Court

Big Pine Key, FL 33043

MLS# A12105725

1539 Lantana Lane, Big Pine Key
Active
5
Active
  • 2 Bedrooms
  • 2 Bathrooms
  • 1,092 Sq Ft
View Details
$995,000
33d on market
2 bd·2 ba·1,092 sqft

1539 Lantana Lane

Big Pine Key, FL 33043

MLS# A12094986